DSL or Cable

DSL or Cable

NewsGroups | Search | Tools
 comp.dcom.modems.cable  Post an article  get this group's latest topics as an RSS feed add this group's latest topics to your My MSN content add this group's latest topics to your My Yahoo content  add this group's latest topics to your Google content  YahooMyWeb Yahoo!  Google Google  Windows Live Favorites Windows Live  del.icio.us del.icio.us  digg digg  Add to Netscape Netscape
Subject Author Date
DSL or Cable LurfysMa 10-18-2005
---> Re: DSL or Cable Robert Nichols10-19-2005
Posted by LurfysMa on October 18, 2005, 4:51 pm
If you were  Registered and logged in, you could reply and use other advanced thread options


I have had DSL for several years. I think it's from XO/Covad. I'm not
sure because I get it through the company that we lease our computers
from so I don't pay the provider directly.

The leasing company is no longer providing broadband service as aprt
of the lease and my lease is up. So, in addition to upgrading our
computers, I also need to decide what to do about broadband.

I liked the DSL initially, but that may have been because I previously
had dial up. Lately, it hasn't been so good. I keep hearing that cable
is much faster. Is that true?

We have Comcast in this area (SF Bay Area). The computers are in a
home office and we have Comcast cable TV. I have found Comcast to be a
big, impersonal, not very freindly company, but the cable TV service
has been pretty good. Are they a reasonable provider and a good
alternative to DSL?

I just got off the phone with them. They say they can install a
business plan for $90/mo that promises 5MB/512KB bandwidth. I thinjk
that's several times what I have now with DSL. Is that valid?

Comcast has several non-business plans that are a lot cheaper. I asked
the guy what the differences are. He said bandwidth and 24/7 tech
support. Would I be better off just getting a home service? I don't
mind the $75-90/mo if the sergvice is really significantly better.

I also called Earthlink. They were my ISP a long time ago and were
pretty good. They tried to sell me a SDSL package for $250/mo that was
only 768KB both ways. The guy said that it would be faster than cable.

How can I tell what speed I will actually see and cut through the
hype?

Also, I would like to make the transition without problems, if
possible. Is there anything I need to do to ensure that I get over to
the new provider smoothly? I am mainly worried about email.

Thanks for any tips or pointers.




--
For email, use Usenet-20031220@spamex.com


Posted by $Bill on October 18, 2005, 7:58 pm


LurfysMa wrote:
> I have had DSL for several years. I think it's from XO/Covad. I'm not
> sure because I get it through the company that we lease our computers
> from so I don't pay the provider directly.
>
> The leasing company is no longer providing broadband service as aprt
> of the lease and my lease is up. So, in addition to upgrading our
> computers, I also need to decide what to do about broadband.
>
> I liked the DSL initially, but that may have been because I previously
> had dial up. Lately, it hasn't been so good. I keep hearing that cable
> is much faster. Is that true?
>
> We have Comcast in this area (SF Bay Area). The computers are in a
> home office and we have Comcast cable TV. I have found Comcast to be a
> big, impersonal, not very freindly company, but the cable TV service
> has been pretty good. Are they a reasonable provider and a good
> alternative to DSL?
>
> I just got off the phone with them. They say they can install a
> business plan for $90/mo that promises 5MB/512KB bandwidth. I thinjk
> that's several times what I have now with DSL. Is that valid?

For $90/mo you can get both and have all the dependability you want.
Get the home cable bandwidth and the dependability of DSL if the
cable goes down. With two different providers, you have much less
chance of down time.

> Comcast has several non-business plans that are a lot cheaper. I asked
> the guy what the differences are. He said bandwidth and 24/7 tech
> support. Would I be better off just getting a home service? I don't
> mind the $75-90/mo if the sergvice is really significantly better.
>
> I also called Earthlink. They were my ISP a long time ago and were
> pretty good. They tried to sell me a SDSL package for $250/mo that was
> only 768KB both ways. The guy said that it would be faster than cable.
>
> How can I tell what speed I will actually see and cut through the
> hype?

Home DSL should be less than $40 from what I've seen.
I generally would avoid business anything - they don't seem practical
to me.

> Also, I would like to make the transition without problems, if
> possible. Is there anything I need to do to ensure that I get over to
> the new provider smoothly? I am mainly worried about email.
>
> Thanks for any tips or pointers.



Posted by Robert Nichols on October 19, 2005, 3:03 pm


:I have had DSL for several years. I think it's from XO/Covad. I'm not
:sure because I get it through the company that we lease our computers
:from so I don't pay the provider directly.
:
:The leasing company is no longer providing broadband service as aprt
:of the lease and my lease is up. So, in addition to upgrading our
:computers, I also need to decide what to do about broadband.
:
:I liked the DSL initially, but that may have been because I previously
:had dial up. Lately, it hasn't been so good. I keep hearing that cable
:is much faster. Is that true?
:
:We have Comcast in this area (SF Bay Area). The computers are in a
:home office and we have Comcast cable TV. I have found Comcast to be a
:big, impersonal, not very freindly company, but the cable TV service
:has been pretty good. Are they a reasonable provider and a good
:alternative to DSL?
:
:I just got off the phone with them. They say they can install a
:business plan for $90/mo that promises 5MB/512KB bandwidth. I thinjk
:that's several times what I have now with DSL. Is that valid?
:
:Comcast has several non-business plans that are a lot cheaper. I asked
:the guy what the differences are. He said bandwidth and 24/7 tech
:support. Would I be better off just getting a home service? I don't
:mind the $75-90/mo if the sergvice is really significantly better.

I think you'll find that using Comcast's home service for running a
business is contrary to Comcast's AUP. If your use of the service falls
within the realm of normal home use (not running any publicly accessible
servers, not sending large amounts of email, not continuously using a
large fraction of your bandwidth, etc.) you could probably get away with
it, but Comcast's tech support for home users can be absolutely abysmal
at times. Can your business stand being without service for 3 or 4 days
while Comcast first sends someone to inspect your PC and cable modem
before dispatching a line tech. to track down their line problem?


--
Bob Nichols AT comcast.net I am "RNichols42"


Posted by LurfysMa on October 19, 2005, 10:28 am


On Wed, 19 Oct 2005 15:03:59 +0000 (UTC), Robert Nichols

>:I have had DSL for several years. I think it's from XO/Covad. I'm not
>:sure because I get it through the company that we lease our computers
>:from so I don't pay the provider directly.
>:
>:The leasing company is no longer providing broadband service as aprt
>:of the lease and my lease is up. So, in addition to upgrading our
>:computers, I also need to decide what to do about broadband.
>:
>:I liked the DSL initially, but that may have been because I previously
>:had dial up. Lately, it hasn't been so good. I keep hearing that cable
>:is much faster. Is that true?
>:
>:We have Comcast in this area (SF Bay Area). The computers are in a
>:home office and we have Comcast cable TV. I have found Comcast to be a
>:big, impersonal, not very freindly company, but the cable TV service
>:has been pretty good. Are they a reasonable provider and a good
>:alternative to DSL?
>:
>:I just got off the phone with them. They say they can install a
>:business plan for $90/mo that promises 5MB/512KB bandwidth. I thinjk
>:that's several times what I have now with DSL. Is that valid?
>:
>:Comcast has several non-business plans that are a lot cheaper. I asked
>:the guy what the differences are. He said bandwidth and 24/7 tech
>:support. Would I be better off just getting a home service? I don't
>:mind the $75-90/mo if the sergvice is really significantly better.
>
>I think you'll find that using Comcast's home service for running a
>business is contrary to Comcast's AUP. If your use of the service falls
>within the realm of normal home use (not running any publicly accessible
>servers, not sending large amounts of email, not continuously using a
>large fraction of your bandwidth, etc.) you could probably get away with
>it, but Comcast's tech support for home users can be absolutely abysmal
>at times. Can your business stand being without service for 3 or 4 days
>while Comcast first sends someone to inspect your PC and cable modem
>before dispatching a line tech. to track down their line problem?

I have no doubt that their t/s for home users is non-existent if not
dangerous. The question is whether their business t/s is any better. I
don't mind paying $100/mo if I got reliable service and responsive
t/s. I guess I'll sign up and see.

--
For email, use Usenet-20031220@spamex.com


Posted by $Bill on October 19, 2005, 11:46 pm


LurfysMa wrote:
>
> I have no doubt that their t/s for home users is non-existent if not
> dangerous. The question is whether their business t/s is any better. I
> don't mind paying $100/mo if I got reliable service and responsive
> t/s. I guess I'll sign up and see.

Why wouldn't you consider getting cable and DSL both for much less money ?
If one goes down, what are chances the other is also down ?
With the additional initial outlay for a dual WAN router ($60 and up), you'd
have the best of both worlds.


Similar ThreadsPosted
Cable modem not working with TV cable plugged in November 2, 2006, 1:34 am
cable Internet cable October 23, 2006, 6:24 am
Do I need a new cable modem? February 15, 2005, 12:00 pm
what cable modem to ge March 30, 2005, 7:15 am
Rca cable question August 4, 2005, 4:52 pm
Speed of cable vs. dsl vs T1? September 27, 2005, 8:10 pm
NTL cable payment? October 19, 2005, 11:13 pm
cable modem November 21, 2005, 10:55 pm
cable modem May 14, 2006, 9:52 am
Move from DSL to Cable July 13, 2006, 9:00 pm

other useful resources:
The Federal Communications Commission (FCC)
Telecommunications Industry Association
Electronic and Software Security Products and Services
International Telecommunication Union

Custom CGI Perl and PHP programming by 1-Script.com

Contact Us | Privacy Policy
The site map in XML format XML site map